SELLING VINYL RECORDS – Ideas from experienced sellers.
This information was found on a Forum of Vinyl Record sellers.

I am not a fan of selling on EBay due to the listing cost, except for a very few titles that could reasonably be expected to auction at a high price. 

I have roughly 6000 records up on GEMM and also on -- GEMM takes a 13% commission and sends payment by check around 3 weeks after the sale. CDandLP's commission is slightly higher and they pay via PayPal up to 6 weeks after the sale.

I also sell on
Discogs but only a small % of my stock is listed there  because Discogs requires you to identify the exact edition of the record  in order to sell it. Discogs charges 8% plus PayPal fees.

On the plus side, I now research first on Discogs for all new arrivals, since their matching system requires a lot less data entry. Discogs pricing tends to be lower than the other two sites. When I am done with a batch, I can download a CSV from there and add the new records to the other two sites.

Related QuestionsMore Answers Below

·                                 Where is the best place to sell old vinyl records?
·                                 What countries buy the most vinyl records?
·                                 What is the best way to sell a collection of Vinyl Music Records (Disco/Dance) from 1975-1985?
·                                 What are the best online marketplaces for buying and selling LP records?
·                                 Where can you sell Vinyl Records online?

Brad Venable, Vinyl enthusiast, former opera singer, music trivia nerd.
The marketplace at Discogs is amazing. It's like a mini eBay, but you're dealing with true enthusiasts for the most part, and any issues I've had were dealt with in a true hobbyist fashion, quickly and properly.

Donald Larter, I'm an amateur musician and have played trombone in a variety of musical groups.
Before you attempt to sell your records online, I recommend you do a search for a handful of your "good condition vinyl records" at CollectorsFrenzy. 

Once there, just type in the pertinent information you find on any given record (such as the name of the record company, the catalog number of the record, the artist's name, and the name of the album). If an item has been sold on eBay in the past few years, it'll pop up in your search results, along with the date it sold, how much it sold for, and other helpful bits of information, including pictures of the item sold. 

Keep in mind, Collectors Frenzy is best for looking up rare and high-demand items which sell for better-than-average amounts of money,  even thousands of bucks occasionally! It is not a site for checking out prices paid for a common record; you can do that easily enough at eBay. 

If you type into the search bar at Frenzy a Michael Jackson record, for example, chances are you won't get any results, unless it happens to be a rare interview record, or a test pressing, or has some attribute  which makes it rare and highly desirable. 

By the way, I've been selling records on eBay for the last 12 years, and while I have a few complaints about eBay's policies, I've generally done fairly well on the 'Bay. Yes, having to pay listing fees; selling fees; PayPal fees; fees on what I charge my customers for shipping(!); and having occasionally to refund money to a buyer who says he didn't receive his merchandise but wasn't willing to spend a bit more (sometimes quite a bit more, for international buyers) for insurance, or at least delivery confirmation; all these things, and a few more besides, make selling on eBay a mixed bag.

The best way to sell your records, however, is to have your own website, which requires you have a way (read, "a good, tech-savvy friend who is great at building websites for little or no money") to get your product out there, which means, in part, having searchers find you in the top 10 of their search results! I hear there's a real art to that. You'll also need to think about other things as well, such as  how you're going to process payments, tax considerations, and probably much more. 

Finally, if you decide to give eBay a chance, and if you're anything like me and are "business-sense challenged," you'll probably wind up just breaking even--if you're lucky! But hey, you'll learn a lot in the process, including 1) how best to package records so they'll arrive safely; 2) how to fill out customs forms for your overseas customers; 3) how to describe accurately--using Goldmine grading standards for example--the condition your records are in; 4) how to "play grade" a record, if you're going to offer that valuable service to your customers [I do!]; 5) how to deal with picky customers who feel you've exaggerated a record's condition; 6) how to share your "profits" with eBay; 7) how to photograph your albums to best advantage and then upload your pix to your listings (with judicious editing, of course); 8) how to prepare and store a template on eBay so that you needn't waste time entering the same information over and over again in each of your listings;  9) how to decide on a fair price for your items and what the best way to list them might be (auction, buy it now, best offer accepted); and 10) how and where to store the records which do not sell--that is, until you decide to donate them to Goodwill! 

I've probably eliminated some steps in the learning curve, but these ten are the main ones! Bottom line: wanting to sell your records and actually selling them are two completely different animals. 

 Best wishes to you!

Jeremy Rollinson, Event Technology & WiFi Pioneer. Backstage catering critic. Collector of Viny...

I'd go with Discogs as you can see a reasonable representation of market value for the records you want to sell broken down by condition. As someone who collects and attends a number of BYO Vinyl nights I can attest to the fact that you also have access to a broad base of collectors worldwide.

I have successfully bought and sold many records on You can find a pre existing track listing for more or less any record if you put in the catalogue number, and you can also see what the same record in the same condition usually goes for. You then set the price - no auction, so it is more like Amazon, but fees are much more reasonable

I'm a regular eBay seller & records are my personal favorite things to sell. As a venue for used or garage sale like items, eBay is a pretty good fit for Lps, since most of them are used. (Vinyl today is being pressed again for more contemporary music & retro reissues; and popularity is for a vintage medium at a high since the almost faded years of 1990s / in contrast CDs are at their lowest) Side note: why are records gaining such a niche popularity re: RSD etc record store day.. Because there's a bit more involved in listening experience, they sound neat sometimes better than the crisp precise digital formats & tactical approach is at the top with graphics and eye alluring art (you can hold in your hands!)
EBay is a staple for thousands and more a day of listings for vintage vinyl records and the like. Many collectors, novices and people who have an interest in the medium visit records for sale on eBay. It has become I believe the pricing for collectible records (there value based on recent sales of similar and like items) and remains to be the best auction site for this offering.

I hope to see you soon active 

Best Regards

johnny sassoli

I m a seller at ebay and I m generally satisfied. 
I was on musicstack once but not any more

I also start selling to a new  marketplace: e-Record Fair 
They charge very low selling fees (4%) and if you use paypal you are safe.

They send an invoice once or twice a month and they are very polite and hellpfull if you need something. You can sent them your inventory on an xls file and they wiil upload it for you for free.

They also allow trades between users. They made an interesting trade platform   and there is a small fixed fee for that 
You can also upload real pictures of your item.

Very very promissing...

Wayne Mansfield, Social Media Pioneer, Merlot lover, Flat White Coffee drinker Activist for life
If you want to "touch and feel" experience for the buyer, I recommend the local version of Gumtree. We have used the Perth version to buy and sell comics with great success. Often the look of vinyl is as important as the sound.
5.3k Views · View Upvotes

Having literally thousands of items, I find the best way to sell them is via my own website. It takes a lot of time and effort but it's worth it in the end. Then you can use various other online resources to make interested parties aware of what you have and you've got total control over the whole process (and no listing fees). I used to sell on eBay but I hated the way they tried to dictate your postage rates. It got messy having to work around that. specalising in original vinyl from the 1950s onwards. Large range of 78 rpm gramophone records also available.

I TOO and looking to list (or download) my listing of 1,000 records I've inherited and am hoping to receive and select the best offers. HOW do I DO this? I am told that Ebay has a method ("click-on") for doing this, and that this is the "best" method. I'm also told that selecting the TYPE of music you have will enhance your potential for sale. I'm also told that "public auctions" can, and are "happy" to do this.. WHO knows...?

Related Questions

·                                 Where can I sell vinyl records?
·                                 What is the best place to buy vinyl records with mp3 downloads?
·                                 Home Audio: What is the best method to clean vinyl records?
·                                 What are vinyl records worth?
·                                 How do cold temperatures affect vinyl records?
·                                 What are some good storage ideas for vinyl records?
·                                 How profitable is the business of selling imported vinyl records?
·                                 Vinyl Records: What materials are good for a turntable mat?
·                                 How much does a vinyl record weigh?
·                                 Who makes the best vinyl record needles and cartridges in the world?
·                                 Where is the best marketplace for selling vinyl records?
·                                 Is selling vinyl and CDs online a viable business, e.g. is profitable?

·                                 What are some things that are not readily available in the US that I can import and sell for profit?
·                                 Where can I sell vinyl records?
·                                 Where is the best place to sell old vinyl records?
·                                 Where can you sell Vinyl Records online?
·                                 How can I easily sell 100 vinyl records online?
·                                 How can a record store become a viable, profitable business in this day and age?
·                                 Is selling vinyl and CDs online a viable business, e.g. is profitable?
·                                 Where is the cheapest and best place to sell vinyl records and cd's online?
·                                 Where's the best place to sell vinyl records online?
·                                 How many vinyl records does a top artist sell?
·                                 Where is the best marketplace for selling vinyl records?
·                                 How profitable is the recording studio business?
·                                 Is selling on Amazon a profitable business?
·                                 Is selling on ecommerce profitable business?
·                                 How do vinyl records work?
·                                 Is it true that record players have the best sound quality?
·                                 Is call recording important for businesses?
·                                 Does import/export business is profitable?

Sell vinyl records online

Think setting up an ecommerce store is difficult? Not with Shopify! We offer a proven, systematic solution that supports you through every step of the process from choosing and customizing your design to processing credit cards and managing inventory. With our help, you’ll be selling records online sooner than you think.
Try Shopify for free